Jon Wilner
In each of the past three years, the conference has produced just three first-round selections.
This year, four players are expected to be picked on Day One, and a fifth name might be called, as well.
Oregon edge rusher Kayvon Thibodeaux, USC receiver Drake London, Utah linebacker Devin Lloyd and Washington cornerback Trent McDuffie are considered first-round locks by draft analysts.
A second Washington cornerback, Kyler Gordon, is viewed as a borderline Day One prospect.
Success in the first round matters, particularly on the recruiting trail. Elite prospects from the West Coast are motivated by two factors to sign with powerhouses elsewhere: The chance to participate in the College Football Playoff, and the lure of becoming a first-round pick.
On both fronts, the Pac-12 is lagging: It hasn’t placed a team in the CFP since the 2016 season and typically generates fewer first-round selections than most peers.
First-round picks by Power Five conference from 2019-21:
SEC: 36
Big Ten: 19
ACC: 16
Pac-12: 9
Big 12: 8
(The list of Pac-12 first-round picks over the past decade, along with other draft data, is below.)
“The Pac-12 isn’t in its golden age,” said Randy Mueller, a former NFL general manager (Miami and New Orleans) who runs a Seattle-based scouting service.
“The difference between out here and the schools in the east is the big guys. You watch some of those teams play, and on the lines, it’s a different game. And the exodus of high school quarterbacks going other places hasn’t helped.”
Only one Pac-12 quarterback was picked last year — Stanford’s Davis Mills, in the third round — and the outlook is bleaker this week.
But three quarterbacks from the Pac-12 footprint who played elsewhere should be selected, possibly in the high rounds: Iowa State’s Brock Purdy (Gilbert, Arizona), Nevada’s Carson Strong (Vacaville, California) and Mississippi’s Matt Corral (Ventura, California).
“When you lose top quarterbacks in recruiting and then you also lose them to transfers, you end up struggling,” Mueller said.
How far has the Pac-12’s overall talent production fallen?
The nine first-round picks produced over the past three years equal the number from a single draft in the middle of the last decade.
In 2015, the conference had nine Day One picks. Not surprisingly, that draft followed one of the best regular seasons in conference history with Oregon reaching the College Football Playoff and six teams included in the end-of-season AP top-25 poll.
The paucity of first-rounders in recent years tracks closely with the dearth of playoff participants and ranked teams.
“It’s a vicious cycle,” Mueller said.
The lack of first-rounders and playoff success prompts elite recruits to sign elsewhere, which further undermines the product and exacerbates the recruiting challenges.
Or as Stanford coach David Shaw explained last year: “There’s that cycle of, if you want great players to come into your program, you have to show them that you can help great players improve and live that NFL dream.”
*** Mueller on the prospects
Mueller, the 2000 NFL Executive of the Year, offered his thoughts on a handful of Pac-12 prospects:
UCLA TE Greg Dulcich: “He’s solid, not as flashy as some of the guys. But it’s not a great year for tight ends.”
Washington CB Trent McDuffie: “His 40 time (at the combine) doesn’t scare me off because he plays fast. I thought the rest of his workout was exceptional.”
Utah LB Devin Lloyd: “The guy is special. People think he’s an inside linebacker. I think he can play everywhere — he’s beyond any scheme. And he’s a sleeper as a pass rusher.”
USC WR Drake London: “There’s less consensus with him because of the (ankle) injury and his speed. Some people have him as the highest-rated receiver, and some don’t even have him in their top five.”
Oregon State TB BJ Baylor: “He’s a sleeper. He didn’t go to the combine, but he’s 220 pounds and has a little juice. I see him as an effective NFL back. He jumped out on film.”
*** Pac-12 first-round selections since conference expansion (2011 football season)
2012
1. Stanford QB Andrew Luck (Indianapolis)
4. USC OT Matt Kalil (Minnesota)
24. Stanford OG David DeCastro (Pittsburgh)
28. USC LB Nick Perry (Green Bay)
2013
3. Oregon DE Dion Jordan (Miami)
14. Utah DT Star Lotulelei (Carolina)
20. Oregon OG Kyle Long (Chicago)
22. Washington CB Desmond Trufant (Atlanta)
26. UCLA DE Datone Jones (Green Bay)
2014
9. UCLA LB Anthony Barr (Minnesota)
20. Oregon State WR Brandin Cooks (New Orleans)
27. WSU S Deone Bucannon (Arizona)
2015
2. Oregon QB Marcus Mariota (Tennessee)
6. USC DE Leonard Williams (Jets)
12. Washington DT Danny Shelton (Cleveland)
13. Stanford OT Andrus Peat (New Orleans)
17. Oregon DE Arik Armstead (San Francisco)
18. Washington CB Marcus Peters (Kansas City)
20. USC WR Nelson Agholor (Philadelphia)
25. Washington LB Shaq Thompson (Carolina)
30. ASU S Damarious Randall (Green Bay)
2016
1. Cal QB Jared Goff (Rams)
7. Oregon DE DeForest Buckner (San Francisco)
27. UCLA DT Kenny Clark (Green Bay)
28. Stanford OG Joshua Garnett (San Francisco)
2017
3. Stanford DE Solomon Thomas (San Francisco)
8. Stanford TB Christian McCaffrey (Carolina)
9. Washington WR John Ross (Cincinnati)
18. USC CB Adoree Jackson (Tennessee)
20. Utah OT Garett Bolles (Denver)
26. UCLA DE Tak McKinley (Atlanta)
2018
3. USC QB Sam Darnold (Jets)
10. UCLA QB Josh Rosen (Arizona)
12. Washington DT Vita Vea (Tampa Bay)
15. UCLA OT Kolton Miller (Las Vegas)
2019
22. WSU OT Andre Dillard (Philadelphia)
31. Washington OT Kaleb McGary (Atlanta)
32. ASU WR N’Keal Harry (New England)
2020
6. Oregon QB Justin Herbert (Chargers)
18. USC OT Austin Jackson (Miami)
25. ASU WR Brandon Aiyuk (San Francisco)
2021
7. Oregon OT Penei Sewell (Detroit)
14. USC OG Alijah Vera-Tucker (Jets)
32. Washington DE Joe Tryon (Tampa Bay)
*** Pac-12 first-round picks per year since expansion:
2012: 4
2013: 5
2014: 3
2015: 9
2016: 4
2017: 6
2018: 4
2019: 3
2020: 3
2021: 3
*** Pac-12 first-round picks since expansion, per school:
USC: 8
Washington: 8
Oregon: 7
Stanford: 6
UCLA: 6
ASU: 3
Utah: 2
Washington State: 2
Cal: 1
Oregon State: 1
Arizona: 0
Colorado: 0
Support the Hotline: Receive three months of unlimited access for just 99 cents. Yep, that’s 99 cents for 90 days, with the option to cancel anytime. Details are here, and thanks for your support.
*** Send suggestions, comments and tips (confidentiality guaranteed) to pac12hotline@bayareanewsgroup.com or call 408-920-5716
*** Follow me on Twitter: @WilnerHotline
*** Pac-12 Hotline is not endorsed or sponsored by the Pac-12 Conference, and the views expressed herein do not necessarily reflect the views of the Conference.
