Wilner Hotline – USC Fires Helton as Head Coach, What’s Next?

Former Southern California head coach Clay Helton (AP Photo/Ashley Landis)

Story by Jon Wilner 


USC’s dismissal of Clay Helton on Monday, two days after another embarrassing loss, was jolting.

Not because Helton deserved to keep his job after so many years of stagnation.

Not because the evidence was flimsy.

Not because we’re only two weeks into the season.

But because the movie was so unlike the USC that we had come to know — the USC that accepted mediocrity from its blue-blood football program and handled administrative matters with a knack for incompetence.

But athletic director Mike Bohn, on the job for less than two years, isn’t a former USC player collecting a paycheck and playing golf and signing autographs and living forever in 1973.

Bohn is a real college sports administrator with experience in the field who sees the landscape and recognizes this is a moment in time the Trojans cannot afford to let pass.

And that moment has nothing to do with which coaches may or may be available when it comes time to make the hire.

Instant reaction:

— The wording in Bohn’s statement was exactly what USC fans want to hear and, frankly, what the fans of a program with seven AP national titles and seven Heismans deserve to hear.

“I want to be exceptionally clear: our university and its leadership are committed to winning national championships and returning USC football to glory.”

Bohn’s statement also covered his bases, noting that the Trojans have plowed immense resources into the football program and weren’t willing to watch them go to waste:

“The added resources carried significantly increased expectations for our team’s performance, and it is already evident that, despite the enhancements, those expectations would not be met without a change in leadership.”

USC spent two years refurbishing the body of the program and hoping that would fix the head.

But the program’s greatest flaws — the lack of accountability, discipline, and toughness — were never going to change without new leadership.

— It’s the third time in the past decade the Trojans have fired a coach during the season — first Lane Kiffin, then Steve Sarkisian, now Helton.

But this end-game could be different. We don’t expect Bohn to elevate Donte Williams, the interim head coach, to permanent. We don’t expect Bohn to name a former USC player as the next coach.

A national search will be conducted with deep pockets and a willingness to devote whatever resources are necessary to find the right coach. A coach is worthy of USC’s tradition.

Maybe it’s Bill O’Brien or Luke Fickell or Matt Campbell or Bob Stoops.

But it won’t be a former player or current assistant.

— It’s impossible to watch Bohn and president Carol Folt move decisively without thinking the Trojans wasted three years with Helton.

At the end of the 2018 season — after the Trojans had gone 5-7 and it was obvious to anyone with football sense that Helton could never remake USC into USC — athletic director Lynn Swann released his infamous statement of support.

From there, it has been Groundhog Clay, one year after the next with Helton on the hot seat in some way, shape, or form.

And for what?

Sure, the Trojans won the South last season; they stumbled and recovered on the recruiting trail, but the on-field product is essentially the same.

Three years, wasted.

All that potential wasted.

— The move is bad for Pac-12 teams and good for the Pac-12.

Bad for the teams because the Trojans might hire a coach who maximizes the program’s potential, dominates on the recruiting trail, and lays waste to the conference — essentially, Pete Carroll II.

Good for the Pac-12 because the conference needs USC to thrive like it needs UCLA basketball to thrive.

If the Trojans are elite, it elevates the Pac-12 in a way that Oregon being elite or Washington being elite does not.

— The decision cannot be evaluated in the vacuum of the present or the recent past, where a former dynasty, battered and wrecked, is finally out of patience.

It’s also about the future.

And what’s coming around the bend?

Only the Pac-12 galvanizing behind new commissioner George Kliavkoff.

And the alliance with the Big Ten and ACC.

And the expansion of the College Football Playoff.

And the Pac-12’s media rights negotiations.

And the potential for additional realignment.

And the restructuring of the NCAA, perhaps with the Power Five eventually breaking into two tiers and the top brands forming a mini-NFL.

Those are huge issues.

USC wants to be a leader in the conference, wants to own leverage at the table and in the back rooms, wants to be part of the club with Alabama and Ohio State and Oklahoma that sets the agenda and blazes the path to whatever the sport becomes.

And for that to happen, the Trojans must be the Trojans.

They must have an elite coach, and they must win at an elite level.

Bohn knows it.

Helton was never going to take them there.

Bohn knew it.

It took an athletic director with no USC ties to make the move that gave USC the chance to be USC again.

The present and the future are at stake for the Trojans and the conference.

Support the Hotline: Receive three months of unlimited access for just 99 cents. Yep, that’s 99 cents for 90 days, with the option to cancel anytime. Details are here, and thanks for your support.

*** Send suggestions, comments, and tips (confidentiality guaranteed) to pac12hotline@bayareanewsgroup.com or call 408-920-5716

*** Follow me on Twitter: @WilnerHotline

*** Pac-12 Hotline is not endorsed or sponsored by the Pac-12 Conference, and the views expressed herein do not necessarily reflect the views of the Conference.